<< Back to Clans Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 2 of 2   
Clan Cup and Clan Teams Cup Suggestions Box: 2026-10-02 10:37:53


Bodski 
Level 62
Report
I am open to making changes to the cups, however, I should like to retain the following qualities:

1. They should be 'light touch' events so one Game at a time for each Cup seems good;
2. They should be Clan focussed; and
3. They should have an element of randomness/jeopardy.

Changes from last year:

- Clan protection is afforded in Round 1 to prevent Squads from the same Clan playing each other in the First Round; and
- Byes were made in Round 1 to ensure that nobody benefited from a bye in more crucial later Rounds.

Possible future changes:

- The Template pool for Clan Cup may be revised although I think that the mtl Templates provide a good, well known mix with an appropriate number of non-standard ones;

- The Template pool for Clan Teams Cup may be revised. The current list was arbitrarily selected by myself and includes the highly unpopular Crimea Army Cap. Should that Template remain, with it being part of the jeopardy that you may end up playing it, or should it be replaced by something else ? Are there any other suggestions ? Things I have considered include a WR 2v2 Template which may be something new (e.g. 2v2 Malvia or Tor-ture WR) or a Commerce Template. Since the selection of these Templates was made by me, I think that it is appropriate to open that up for wider discussion.

Guidance on Template Selection

Templates must be strategic, so no Small Earth, Lottery or other such Templates will be considered, however, an element of weirdness (such as Blitzkrieg or INSS) should feature as should most of the strategic features available in War.app (e.g. LD, MA, WR, etc.).

I am open to a small annual variation providing that this involves very low administration. An example of this may be that the Cup winner makes to Template changes and the runner up makes one. We should have a pool of Templates to chose from in this respect although other Templates could be added to the pool over time.

I note that there is very little use of Commerce settings in the Strategic community which should probably be remedied.

No changes will be made to the current competitions which are on-going

If there are any other issues, comments or suggested improvements to any part of the Clan Cups, please comment here so that I have all information in one place.

Finally, running these events is quite time consuming so if anyone would like to volunteer to help me or take over one or both Cups, please let me know.
Clan Cup and Clan Teams Cup Suggestions Box: 2026-10-20 19:17:30


JK_3 
Level 64
Report
The MTL is the golden standard for strategic templates, but I think it might be fun if its expanded more. And not just the common/good strategic templates that just aren't on the MTL or that have already been retired for it.

Same can be said for the team templates, more variety would be fun. But there is already a lack of properly tested and well known team templates.

For next CC I would also like to see some modded templates too if that can be organised, but that depends a bit on your budget. A modded game is 2 coins per player, and with the large template pool the expected coin cost per game then drops to almost zero.

Having a winner update a single template would limit the selection too much i.m.o., just pick all available template and only remove those that are "too bad" by your own judgement.
But I do like the variety, veering away from known/common templates might scare away the more casual players.

RE Commerce: A good commerce template would be nice, but usually commerce templates either can be won by just ignoring commerce and playing like normal, or commerce is key to the template and its city spam all over. I hope the new commerce settings can bring a balance to this.

If you need someone to help out with the next season, I'm sure plenty of people don't mind helping a bit!
Give me a shout if you need and I might be available too 😅
Posts 1 - 2 of 2